SHAME: (noun) a painful emotion caused by a strong sense of guilt, embarrassment, unworthiness, or disgrace
REGRET: (verb) to remember with distress or longing ; (noun) sorrow aroused by circumstances beyond one's control or power to repair
So which one is worse? Does regret cause shame? Does shame cause regret? Are they even related? I am not sure. I don't think that they have a causal relationship, but I do think they often go hand-in-hand. In 3 different dictionary definitions "a painful emotion" was associated with shame. And I think it is true. I think that ultimately shame is a very painful emotion, one that we would rather not experience. I have felt shame more than once in my own life and know that in addition to it being unpleasant, it is almost always humbling. I have been brought to my knees with the weight of shame, for it is a heavy burden to bear. There, on my knees, I seem to want to do anything to make it go away, to loosen the rocks that pull on my heart. Shame seems to hit right there in the middle of my chest, precisely where my heart is. Of course I believe the root of shame is guilt, but guilt seems to be less painful for it can be reasoned away. Shame puts more demand on the heart. It almost screams for reconciliation, for some type of recovery, for some type of return home. Shame has that kind of power, the kind of power that makes you feel as though you can never go home again, the kind of power that declares you to be impotent and unimportant and ultimately wrong.
Is shame a natural part of life? Or is it something we do to ourselves, something we put on ourselves? I'm not 100% certain on the answers to these questions. I think that we are human and therefore will make mistakes of varying gravities. Those mistakes that hurt other people are the ones that bring on the most shame. For example, I do not feel shame for being late for work. On the other hand I feel much shame for lashing out at my mother and hurting her feelings. I think shame is somewhat a part of life, but I also think that we can manufacture shame by constantly feeling guilty about something. I think we can be conditioned to feel guilty for even the slightest infraction and therefore feel shame on a daily basis. But I also think we can learn to let some things go with the knowledge that guilt and the shame that follows it can be dangerous for us, unhealthy as it diminishes our self-worth.
I have learned that guilt can be instilled into children by their parents. These are the children who grow up and constantly feel like they have to live up to something or someone; they are the ones that are always doing things for others, as if they are trying to make up for something bad they did. I have seen firsthand how crippling this can be. It is a race away from shame, a way
not to feel that ever-present guilt. The trick is to know that sometimes we will mess up in a big way and we will be ashamed of ourselves, and we will also know what to do to make up for it, we will know how to return home with our head held high and ask for forgiveness.
What to do with regret? It is very hard to live in this world and not have regrets. I think everyone regrets something, some more than others. Some people live their life regretting their past and trying to make up for it or re-create the past so they can do it all over again but this time with that 20/20 hindsight ahead of them. Others basically have no regrets. They act and if they mess up, well then they deal with the consequences and move on. They let it go. One part of regret is not being able to let a mistake go. And yet it is critical that we do let our regrets go, for they can be poison to our futures. Regrets can make us scared creatures who cannot go after certain challenges for fear of failure and more regret. They can prevent us from entering into new relationships for fear of obtaining even more regret.
As with shame, regret is unavoidable. We are human and we make mistakes. Sometimes we make mistakes that cannot be repaired; sometimes we make mistakes that will never be forgotten. And we regret our actions or our reactions. We look back upon those mistakes with "distress". Regret can cause pain just like shame, but I don't think regret causes the same kind of heart bending pain shame does. I don't think regret can bring you to your knees; I think it can bring you to your senses. Regret can cause a person to feel unworthy, but only if they allow this to happen. We can control regret more than we can shame. Regret can teach us, shame only hurts us. But regret, regret can show us how to be better people. If you give into regret and don't let it go after it has taught its last lesson, you end up on the floor scared and cold.
No one wants to feel ashamed. No one wants to deal with regret. Shame can humble us like nothing else can and regret can be a great teacher. We should try to avoid both, but know that life goes on and if we don't hold on to the past we can be free to explore the world with open eyes and an open heart, not afraid to go deep into the mountains or farther down the river.